On the Janiculum Hill, where for more than a hundred and thirty years the American Academy in Rome has welcomed some of the most brilliant artists and scholars from the United States, the atmosphere has never been so tense. It all stems from a decision that few can make sense of: the institution's leadership has chosen not to renew the appointment of Director Aliza S. Wong, whose term will end in 2027. No reason has been made public, and no criticism appears to have been raised about her performance. It is precisely this silence that has turned a routine change of leadership into a case that is tearing the Academy's community apart.
Wong, a historian of modern Italy who came to Rome from Texas Tech University, has led the Via Angelo Masina campus since July 2022. She is the 25th director and the first woman of Chinese descent to hold the position in the institution's history. In four years she has done what the Academy had long been striving for: opening its gates to the city, building ties with Roman artists, scholars, museums, and foundations, and bringing the Janiculum back to the center of cultural exchange between Italy and the United States. It is a positive change that we have witnessed firsthand. Over these years Wong has drawn on her cultural and historical knowledge of our country and placed it at the Academy's service, while also showing great personal and managerial qualities. That change matters all the more in difficult years like the ones we are living through.
I am not the only one to attest to this important change, and she is certainly not the one saying it. Those who live the Academy every day have put it in writing, in the form of a petition. Dozens of fellows and advisors have chosen to speak out personally in a letter addressed to the Board of Trustees, chaired by architect Calvin Tsao, asking that the director be confirmed for a new term. It is an initiative that, as far as anyone familiar with the institution can recall, has no precedent.
The text is measured in tone and scathing in substance. "Since Aliza arrived in 2022, we have seen the Academy change in ways that are visible and deeply felt," write the signatories, who attribute much of that change "to her vision, her commitment to the community, and her effective efforts to cultivate meaningful relationships between the institution and the city of Rome." And further: "The Academy is no longer an island on the Janiculum. It is a place Romans seek out, a true center of exchange between Italy and the United States."
The letter stresses a point that does not show up on any balance sheet but is decisive for a community of residents: the climate inside the institution. Staff morale, it says, has improved in large part thanks to her, and the fellows feel supported. "For an institution whose purpose is to nurture creative and scholarly work, that atmosphere is not a luxury. It is the foundation of everything else."
Given a record like that, the question is inevitable: why? The director in Rome reports directly to the president and CEO, historian Peter N. Miller, who has led the Academy from its New York offices since July 2023. It is to him, before anyone else, that the community is looking for an account of a choice that, as things stand, appears entirely unexplained. The petition puts him in a seriously awkward position, all the more so because his own appointment is reportedly nearing its end: a president at the close of his term dismissing a well-regarded director, leaving his successor a divided institution and a transition to be built from scratch.
The Academy has no shareholders to answer to. It is a nonprofit organization under U.S. law, governed by a board of about forty trustees. Its members include names such as Stephen Greenblatt, David Kertzer, and Carrie Mae Weems, along with Italians of the stature of Alessia Antinori and Francesco Starace. It is to them that the letter is addressed, and it is from them that the Janiculum community awaits an answer that, so far, has not come from New York.
The timing, moreover, could hardly be worse. Tax filings in the United States describe an Academy that is not at risk of collapse, since it can count on an endowment of about $178 million, but that is going through a period of evident strain. In the fiscal year that ended in August 2025, contributions, bequests, and grants came to about $6.38 million, compared with $9.93 million the previous year: a drop of 35.7 percent. Total revenue fell from $22.5 million to $13.5 million, and the year closed with an operating deficit of about $2.2 million.
Swings of this kind are not unusual in the American nonprofit world, but here they come on top of a hostile environment. Miller himself acknowledged as much in his January 2026 State of the Academy address, speaking of a gradual decline in support and of across-the-board cuts to funding for culture and humanities research in the United States. For an organization that relies on private philanthropy for nearly half of its revenue, it is a warning sign not to be underestimated.
This is where the decision not to reappoint Wong stops being a matter of personalities and becomes a matter of institutional governance. When donors grow more cautious, the most precious capital is trust: the trust of benefactors, of partner institutions, of the city that hosts the Academy. The signatories say so plainly: the relationships built in Rome take years to cultivate and can easily be lost in a transition. Another term would make it possible to turn them into lasting partnerships and to preserve the momentum the Academy enjoys today.
Giving all this up without a word of explanation, while the finances call for stability and the community calls for continuity, is a decision the leadership cannot brush off as business as usual. The Board of Trustees now has two paths. If there are reasons not to reappoint Aliza Wong, it has a duty to make them known to the fellows, advisors, and supporters who are openly asking for them. If there are none, it has the chance to correct course and listen to those who are the soul of the Academy. On the Janiculum, continued silence is no longer an option.
(Associated Medias) - All rights reserved